Performance Reviews of MSFS 2024 on Xbox Series X vs. PC

Overview
The performance of Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 (MSFS 2024) on Xbox Series X compared to a well-equipped PC has been a hot topic among users and reviewers. The discussion centers around graphical fidelity, frame rates, and overall user experience, highlighting the strengths and limitations of each platform.

Xbox Series X Performance

1. Struggles with Graphics: Several reviews indicate that the Xbox Series X struggles to deliver the same level of graphical performance as a PC with recommended specifications. Users have noted that the graphics quality on the console appears "objectively worse" than MSFS 2020, with issues such as screen tearing and lower texture detail compared to what is achievable on PC (source: Forums Discussion).

2. Hardware Limitations: Critics emphasize that the hardware of the Series X may not be powerful enough to effectively handle MSFS 2024's demands. The console may fall short in scenarios requiring high processing power and graphical capabilities, which are better accommodated by a gaming PC (source: Forums Discussion).

3. User Experience: The user feedback on forums indicates that while the Xbox provides a more accessible platform for casual gamers, dedicated sim enthusiasts may find the experience lacking in comparison to PC, which offers better graphics, peripheral support, and potential VR capabilities (source: Reddit Discussion).

PC Performance with Recommended Specs

1. Superior Graphics and Performance: PCs designed with the recommended specifications for MSFS 2024 demonstrate significantly better graphical fidelity and frame rates. For example, configurations utilizing high-end components like an RTX 4090 graphics card and an i9 13900K CPU can run the game at ultra settings, delivering stunning visuals (source: YouTube Graphics Comparison).

2. Flexibility with Settings: A major advantage of running MSFS 2024 on a PC lies in the ability to adjust settings to optimize performance based on individual hardware capabilities. Users can fine-tune their setups to prioritize either performance or graphics, ensuring a tailored experience (source: Tom's Hardware PC Performance Testing).

3. Overall Experience: The PC version not only supports advanced graphical settings but also provides better peripheral usage (joysticks, yokes, VR), which enhances realism and immersion. The enhanced processing capabilities of PCs lead to smoother gameplay and enhanced simulation realism.

Conclusion

In summary, when comparing the performance of MSFS 2024 on Xbox Series X versus a PC that meets recommended specifications, the general consensus is that the PC outperforms the Xbox significantly in terms of graphics, flexibility, and overall player experience. The limitations of the Xbox Series X in handling the demanding nature of the game suggest that for serious flight simulation enthusiasts, a powerful PC setup is the clear choice. For casual players, however, the Xbox may still offer an enjoyable experience, albeit with compromises on visual fidelity and performance.The performance of Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 (MSFS 2024) has been a topic of considerable discussion regarding its comparison between the Xbox Series X and a PC that meets the recommended specifications. Here's a detailed summary based on various reviews and insights gathered from multiple sources.

Performance Comparison

Xbox Series X vs PC

1. Hardware Limitations: Several sources highlight that the Xbox Series X, while powerful, struggles to run MSFS 2024 as effectively as a well-configured PC. Users on a dedicated forum noted that the hardware available in the Xbox Series X isn't sufficient to handle the game's intensive demands. It reportedly struggles with aspects such as frame rates and visual fidelity, which leads to a less immersive experience when compared to PCs equipped with high-end graphics cards and processors (source).

2. Graphics and Visual Quality: Comparisons between the graphics on Xbox Series X and PC running at ultra settings reveal a significant disparity in graphics quality. A YouTube comparison video highlighted that a PC equipped with an RTX 4090 can deliver visually superior graphics, draw distances, and textures that the Xbox Series X cannot match (source). Additionally, some users reported that the visuals appear "objectively worse" on the Xbox Series X compared to its predecessor, MSFS 2020, due to issues such as screen tearing and the inability to utilize v-sync effectively (source).

3. User Experience: From discussions on Reddit, it's observed that while the Xbox Series X provides a satisfactory simming experience, the overall experience is not as robust as what a PC setup offers with supportive peripherals and VR capabilities. Users recognized that Xbox players might not experience a significant decrease in enjoyment, especially if they don't have access to high-spec PCs, but those who do will notice the quality difference (source).

4. Recommended PC Specs: A PC with the recommended specifications—including a Ryzen 7 2700X or Intel Core i7-10700K, paired with a GPU like the Radeon RX 5700 XT or GeForce RTX 2080—offers a markedly improved experience with better graphical output and smoother gameplay. The performance testing indicated that these configurations lead to significantly better rendering, load times, and overall gaming performance (source).

Conclusion

Overall, while MSFS 2024 runs on both Xbox Series X and PC, the latter, especially with high-end specifications, outperforms the console in graphics, performance, and gameplay experience. Xbox users may find the game enjoyable but will likely see limitations in visual fidelity and performance when compared to a capable gaming PC. Therefore, for dedicated flight simulation enthusiasts seeking the best experience, investing in a high-performance PC setup is highly recommended. For further visuals and detailed discussions, one can refer to comparative graphics videos and community discussions.

Sources

Xbox Series X is struggling to run MSFS 2024 compared to PCFlight Simulator 2024 - PC vs XBOX Graphics Comparison - YouTubeIs MSFS notably better or worse on Xbox Series X or a comparably ...Xbox Series X vs RTX 4080 PC Graphics Comparison - YouTubeQuick question what will be the difference between XBOX X and PC ...FS2024: What Kind of Performance To Expect On Xbox X/S (& PC)This is how MFS 2024 runs on Series X - General Discussion

Related Questions

What is the best platform for Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024?

Will the Xbox Series X run Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024?

Is Xbox series X good for Microsoft Flight Simulator?

How powerful is the Xbox Series X compared to PC?