Based on the themes of your story and the word "misfit," here are some short title suggestions that echo that essence and reflect the eerie, tension-filled atmosphere of your work:

1. Possessed Outsiders
2. Eerie Misfits
3. Tainted Eccentrics
4. Whispers of the Odd
5. Beneath the Eccentric
6. Strange Deviants
7. Haunted Mavericks
8. Sinister Oddballs
9. Anomalous Shadows
10. Chilling Weirdoes

These titles aim to mirror the concept of being a "misfit" while also hinting at the horror elements in your story. If you would like more options or different themes, feel free to ask!

Sources

MISFIT Synonyms: 38 Similar and Opposite Words - Merriam-WebsterSynonyms of misfits - Merriam-Webster17 Synonyms & Antonyms for MISFITS | Thesaurus.comWhat is another word for misfit? - WordHippoMISFIT - 28 Synonyms and Antonyms - Cambridge EnglishDoes anyone know of a word/synonym for "misfit" that is considered ...17 Synonyms & Antonyms for MISFITS - Thesaurus.com

Related Questions

What do you call someone who doesn't fit into society?

What does misfit mean in slang?

What is the idiom for misfit?