Scott Galloway argues that the higher education system has transformed into something resembling a caste system. He suggests that higher education, once a vehicle for social mobility and a means to achieve the American dream, has increasingly become an obstacle for many. Galloway notes that factors such as rising tuition costs and student loan debt create barriers for those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, limiting access to education and reinforcing societal stratification. In his view, the system now favors the wealthy, who can afford to pay for prestigious colleges, while effectively excluding others, thus perpetuating a cycle of inequality.

Galloway also emphasizes that not every student is suited for college, suggesting that many who aren't "college material" could be misled into pursuing degrees that do not align with their skills or interests. He reflects on the influence of parental choices and educational consultants, which can further entrench privilege and diminish the notion of equal opportunity in education.

On the flip side, Charlie Kirk presents reasons why he believes college is not worth the investment. He argues that a college degree has become less valuable in today's job market, as many graduates find themselves underemployed or unable to secure jobs that require a degree. Kirk also criticizes the increasing cost of higher education, indicating that the return on investment is often not justifiable. Furthermore, he highlights that many colleges promote ideologically driven curricula over practical skills, suggesting that alternatives such as vocational training or self-education could provide better paths for success without the financial burden associated with a traditional college education.

In summary, both Galloway and Kirk present compelling critiques of the current state of higher education, highlighting issues of accessibility, relevance, and financial viability.

Sources

Six Ideas to Rescue Higher Education | by Scott Galloway | MarkerHow I Got Here | No Mercy / No MaliceScott Galloway | 35 comments - LinkedInScott Galloway - Understanding the Modern Caste System - TikTokHigher Ed: Enough Already | No Mercy / No MaliceScott Galloway on the future of higher education - FacebookCollege shouldn't be a luxury brand. Scott Galloway joins. - YouTube

Related Questions

What is the biggest problem in higher education?

Is Higher Education good for society?